Levi married Maryland native, Mary Ann Davis, whose family relocated to Marion Township prior to 1840. After their marriage, on Thursday, August 14, 1851, the couple had four children: Margaret Jane, Lydia, Fannie, and John W. who was born just over a month before the Civil War began. By 35 years old, Levi and Mary had accumulated $2,000 worth of real estate in Findlay with a personal estate value of $1,800 (In April 2024, this equates to $74,777.35 and $67,299.61).