THE INFIRMARY

1828

1587 GRANVILLE PIKE
LANCASTER, OH 43130

"THE ASYLUM, WITH ITS CORRUGATED CORRIDORS, WITHHELD WALLS, AND CONCEALING CEILINGS, ENTICE ONE TO ATTEMPT TO EXTRACT ITS LEGEND, ITS SECRETS, WITHOUT GETTING CAUGHT, ALMOST TANTALIZING THE CURIOSITY OF THOSE THAT DARE AND EQUIVOCATE THE PAST"

A DARK DISTANT PAST

Joe McFarland

The Far-Land Legacy
The Publishing Legacy Company

Friday, January 7, 2022

Saturday, May 25, 2024 - UPDATED

Legacy Card for the Fairfield County Infirmary.

BIOGRAPHY

LANCASTER – Staring back from above the cracked cement steps, the Fairfield County Infirmary, noted as one of the most haunted places in Ohio, among the former Mud House Mansion, stands silently off Route 37, Granville Pike, waiting for one to take notice. Originally opened in 1828 as a wood-framed structure, it provided a safe haven for society’s misfits and outcasts who needed shelter, support, and treatments for various illnesses. If one managed to be rehabilitated they would be released back into society. If not, they would spend their remaining days relying on the provision of food, clothing, and medical care from the township officer “overseer of the poor,” a position given to the lowest bidder to care for individuals unable to cope with society.

Photo of the Fairfield County Infirmary.
The Fairfield County Infirmary. Photo taken by Joe McFarland.

The current standing 184-year-old brick building wasn’t built until 1840 when the original wood-framed structure filled to its capacity and demanded more room be made for its inhabitants. This forced an expansion in 1865 to meet those demands when additions were added to allow for laundry and storage facilities and further expansions to the living area and farm land. Additional upgrades came to the Infirmary in 1917 as gas lines were installed for light and heat, and later piping was installed throughout its walls to channel in fresh water by 1926. Its evolution staggered behind that of the country as the infirmary did not incorporate electricity until its installation in 1958. Adequate conditions once filled the Infirmary in the 1920s as county officials dined

with the inmates on occasion. At Christmas, Lancaster residents gathered donations to ensure the disconnected residents received gifts. Events welcomed local bands and orchestras performing entertainment for the elderly while enjoyment of ice cream and music obliterated the concept of time. The asylum, with its corrugated corridors, withheld walls, and concealing ceilings, entice one to attempt to extract its legend, its secrets, without getting caught, almost tantalizing the curiosity of those that dare and equivocate the past. The foundation of the infirmary’s reputation fascinated a group of paranormal investigators to make the trek, touring the location and foray its ancient historical secrets. As guests for three days, the team documented their findings and released “The Forgotten” documentary directed by Matthew Feole, to unveil their findings, available to rent on Amazon.

The “Old Poor House” encased those with mental disorders, severe health affliction, alcoholism, and others who were left with permanent scars tattooed across their flesh. As death drenched continuous through its doors, the county opened a cemetery solely devoted to bury the persons who expired within the enclosed walls. Those not claimed by next of kin, traveling by alias, or unable to secure a proper burial were given a small plot of earth to forever encase their corpse. There only stands a few tombstones as the rest are unmarked graves with untold stories forever silenced by the earth beneath.

 

One ghostly tale tells of Jane Householder, a 73-year-old inmate resident who burned, once flames leapt from the oven and enveloped her clothing in flames. Two staff personnel managed to grab two rugs and smother the flames after they heard her shuttered scream. They successfully distinguished the fire; however, brought no salvation as Jane died nine hours later. Another incident involved an inmate who struck the superintendent across the head with a bar used to stack hay, in 1924. Later it surfaced that the inmate took the opportunity to act in retaliation as Superintendent Floyd Hummel took pleasure in regularly beating inmates in the front yard and across the road working the field callous to witnesses passing by.

Tombstone of Jane Askin.
Tombstone of Jane (Askins) Householder located at the Infirmary cemetery. Photo courtesy of Ancestry.com.

LEGENDS WHO LEFT A LEGACY

Museum Piece for the Infirmary Directors.
Select the image of the Showcase to view the Infirmary Directors.
Photo of the museum display for patients and prisoners.
Select the image of the Showcase to view the Infirmary Patients and Prisoners.
Legacy Card for the Infirmary Cemetery.
Select the image of the Infirmary Card to view the Infirmary Cemetery.

Within the walls, although thought to be revolutionary treatments and innovative exercises at the time, personnel actually induced cruel and extensive punishments to the inmates and patients as the results left disfiguration, further complications, and in severe cases – death.

 

A dungeon upstairs detained those who refused to obey the house rules. Personnel placed the offenders in chains against the wall and quarantined them from the adjacent quarters where travelers stayed. While the travelers worked to earn their keep they attempted to suffocate the screams of those incarcerated. Another jail cell remained below where 24-hour isolation demanded the rules be followed. With the ability to lose yourself to the many levels and corridors, the property housed an active funeral parlor – the morgue shared with the city – an asylum, orphanage, and presented a makeshift haven for weary travelers.

Photo of the Fairfield County Infirmary.

Before the property across the road sold in the 1960s, to make way for the Ohio University to expand with its remote campus, the farmland yielded crop to provide for the inhabitants’ food and a source of income until its funding faded. As the funding dried up so did the care of the inmates as they faced abuse, mistreatment, and malnourishment. This unleashed the dark, eerie energies that stain the walls and plague the halls from the evil demeanor of the doctors and nurses left behind.

 

The Gorsuch company attempted to purchase the property; however, the results they received after a conducted survey of the property yielded data denying the ability to build another building on the lot. Underneath the ground a significant amount of dots, positioned in a grid row, revealed skulls below the surface as the dead were buried vertically to relieve the grave digger the task of excavating such a large section of earth for burial preparations. It is believed there are over 1,200 persons buried in the cemetery with an additional 1,600 buried further behind the property in another section. This defends the stories of the “unrested” dead since they are standing and not laid to rest underneath the earth.

Photo of the Infirmary.
Photo of the Infirmary during the 19th century. Courtesy of Vickie at Pinterest.com.
Photo of the Infirmary. Courtesy of the Visit Fairfield County.org site.

Upon the abandonment of the property, in May 1985, the remaining sixteen inmates were forced to other facilities where care surrounded them until their days’ end or were forced to find their own way in the world.

 

The Infirmary transitioned to county offices for a time after proper equipment was installed to accommodate its new purpose. The structure later succumbed to atrophy where abandonment left it to hold tight its mysteries for the next seven years until Adam Kimmell rescued it from its own estrangement to preserve the history and stories saturating the structure.

 

Once Adam took over the property a former worker of the Clarence E. Miller building, as it was known after the 1986 renovations, stopped to give his personal encounter of the property. He explained how he worked there between 2000-2004 and mentioned that the third-floor cell imprisoned 10-14 mentally ill patients against their will. The screams persisted throughout the workday as he attempted to drown them out just twenty years ago.

 

Kimmell further explained when the undertaker drained the deceased to preserve the body after death, the formaldehyde drained into the local water supply through the active stream below the building, poisoning local residents. The stream remains active today.

 

Adam Kimmell hopes to preserve this ancient relic of Fairfield County’s history and gives tours through the night to see what may linger about once the sun fades into the night and the darkness steers its guests.

PROPERTY OWNERS

Based on Timeline of Ownership
COMING SOON...

Check out who lived in the same place, other landmarks, the cemetery
or select the Fairfield County map to go back to the Legend Page.

The Far-Land Legacy's mascot, Professor Fields.

THE REFERENCES

Dwight Barnes, “Stories of Infirmary Burials Often Undocumented,” Lancaster Eagle-Gazette, Sunday, August 18, 2002, 42.

“Fairfield County Poorhouse,” Ohio Exploration Society. https://www.ohioexploration.com/structures/fairfieldcountypoorhouse/.

Feole, Matthew. Fairfield County Infirmary: The Forgotten. Gateway Paranormal Films.  2020.

PHOTOS

Fairfield County Infirmary. 2024. Digital. VisitFairfieldCounty.org, https://visitfairfieldcounty.org/listings/fairfield-county-infirmary/.

Vickie. Lancaster. Digital. Pinterest.com, https://www.pinterest.com/pin/543106036313138821/.

LEGACY ARTICLE

McFarland, Joe. “A Dark Distant Past: Curing An Infected Infirmary.” The Far-Land Legacy, January 7, 2022. https://thefarlandlegacy.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/03/Vol.-1-Issue-2.pdf.

All Design Elements and Media by The Far-Land Legacy

Fairfield County

The Far-Land Legacy Logo.

EST. 09 DEC 1800