Arthur married Jeanny B. McNeill three years later on Thursday, February 5, 1891, in Fairfield County, Ohio. Soon after, they began to start their life together and had four boys: Webb Isaiah, John Martin, Arthur McNeill, and Herman. While Jeanny was pregnant with their third son, Arthur, they began the process to purchase the Daniel Sifford home on top of the hill of downtown East Main Street. On Wednesday, May 4, 1898, it finally materialized as Arthur presented the largest bid when the property went up for public auction at 154 East Main Street. Sheriff J. W. Stewart commenced the sale of the property from the plaintiff, Daniel Sifford. Arthur purchased the property for $4,666.67 ($174,480.61 in 2024 dollars). It was the highest bid when the property went up for public auction.

Living in downtown Lancaster, practicing law, and raising a family alongside Jeanny, Arthur further gained an appointment from Ohio Governor, George Kilbon Nash, who served as governor from January 8, 1900 – October 28, 1904. Governor Nash appointed Arthur to Ohio Insurance Commissioner in 1900, shortly after he became governor. Governor Myron Timothy Herrick further extended Arthur’s appointed position in 1905, after he became governor. He also served as the director of the insurance companies: Western and Southern Life Insurance Co., Ohio Farmers Insurance Co., and the Credit Life Insurance Co. During this time Arthur put his professional skills to work and through his ambitious attitude he developed the Insurance Department of Ohio from a mere department into a nationally known institution. Through his work the Model Insurance Code of Ohio became about putting him on the map nationally as an insurance lawyer. In high demand, he was well received and requested all across the country to speak on various phases of insurance law at many insurance conventions.

By 1907, Arthur resigned from his seven-year position as the Superintendent of Insurance of Ohio to shift his primary focus on William Howard Taft’s presidential campaign, and in 1908 served as Taft’s campaign manager. Arthur was a strong republican securing appointments by two consecutive republican governors and then focused on Taft’s republican politics, serving as a member of the Republican National Commission until 1912. During President Taft’s term, Arthur, along with Congressman Albert Douglas, recommended his brother-in-law, Henry Clay Drinkle, who married his sister, Kate, to postmaster of the city of Lancaster. Taft agreed and appointed Henry to postmaster on September 1, 1910, as he transitioned away from his law practice.

During this time Arthur built a strong partnership with three other attorneys: Lowry Frances Sater, Augustus Theodore Seymour I, and Edward Livingston Pease. The four founded and established the law firm, Vorys, Sater, Seymour and Pease, LLP in April 1909, located in downtown Columbus. “Arthur devoted himself to law and inhabited a keen legal mind. He appreciated and upheld the integrity and ethics of the law profession with unswerving honesty and integrity.” The still prominent law firm continues to practice law under his name at 52 East Gay Street since 1911. He led the company until his death.

He also gained the position as chairman of the World’s Insurance Congress in San Francisco, California, in 1915.

Arthur Vorys gained a great deal of respect among his fellow colleagues and peers, with the courts, associates at the Bar, and the citizens of both Lancaster and Columbus. A lifelong Republican, a political citizen, and a firm believer in the Constitution of the United States and Government established the forefathers set Vorys high with integrity and prominence. He never actively sought public office, but always managed to assist friends and associates in their pursuits. He would also always seek another other enterprise that would continue to bring success to both Lancaster and Columbus.

When Arthur and Jeanny relocated to Columbus, they moved their family to 682 East Broad Street where they lodged until they could find a proper residence as the 1910 U.S. Census recorded. It was then sometime between then and 1920 they moved into their permanent residence at 441 East Town Street. By 1920 there was no mortgage out on the property.

His two sons, Webb and John, practiced law at Vorys, Sater, Seymour and Pease. Arthur also was a member of the American Bar Association, Ohio Bar Association, and member of World’s Insurance Congress and Methodist Club.

The prominent politician and accomplished attorney of Columbus, Ohio, Arthur Isaiah Vorys, passed away on Thursday, January 26, 1933, at 1 p.m. at his residence located at 441 East Town Street in Columbus, Ohio. He battled with illness for one year prior to his passing.

After Arthur’s death, the citizens of Lancaster took it upon themselves to express their appreciation and respect for his long and successful life and legal career when he started as a member of the Lancaster Bar Association. It was remembered that “no one who knew him well will ever forget the smile, the friendly greeting, that came to him when he returned to Lancaster and especially his annual visit to the Lancaster Fair, which institution he was associated with for many years as an officer, and he never seemed to lose interest in its welfare. By his passing the State of Ohio lost one of its leading citizens the Bar of Ohio, one of its able lawyers, his family an ideal father, and his friends that are uncounted, the influence of a real man.” The words were led by the respectful citizens, Brooks E. Shell, C. A. Radcliffe, and L. G. Silbaugh.